PLUS MEMBERSHIP
Get unlimited access to hundreds of tutorials, expert advice from NYVS Instructors, and more... Sign up now!

Mexio City's water crisis

Uploaded by

RhodriDavies

Views 1,439
Date & Time 10 January 2011, 12:53 am

About this video

At lest hundreds of thousands of residents of Mexico City, the capital of Mexico, are failing to receive a permanent water supply. It is a puzzling problem in a city the Aztecs built on five lakes and which consequently suffers annual flooding. Some analysts are saying that it is an example of the stark divide between rich and poor in the country. Authorities are promising changes to deal with the long-term problem, but solutions have not yet been seen. Published April 24, 2010.

Tags: mexico city | water | rhodri davies

About the Uploader


NYVS Critique

michael Jan 15, 2011, 02:26pm 4 : Helpful Not Helpful

Ok Rhodri, You have an interesting story here and you've done the 'journalism'. The problem is in the execution. A few points and ideas. First, when you shoot things like buildings or fountains or stuff like that, you're probably going to be better off with a tripod. I, personally, am not a fan of tripods but the shake in your shots is not good. If you can't stablilize them so there is absolutely no movement whatsoever, get that tripod. When you interview the water commissioner, note how half the screen (on the left) is fundamentally wasted space. A book shelf. The guy should dominate the screen. OK. Now down to the more significant issues - story structure. What you have delivered here is an essay on the water problem - or more appropriately the unfair distribution of clean water in Mexico City. What makes a really compelling story is character. You need to base the story around a character. You have found two people willing to talk to you about how water impacts on their lives. But all you have done is interview them. Reverse your thinking here. Take the woman (the first one), and build the entire story around her life. show her at home trying to make a meal, wash the dishes - clean up. Where does she get her water from? Show the buckets. How does all this work? Live the story as opposed to reporting it. Make me care about how this situation makes one persons life difficult. One small story I can really care about. Once you have hooked me on that, then show me the fountains. Get the idea?

Comments

vacationlifestylemedia
11:41 pm Tuesday
Feb 8, 2011
As the world becomes more populated, demand for water and shortages of potable water will become an even more important issue. I noticed on one clip that the wind made noise that interfered with one of your interviews. If you use a foam or fake fur "dead cat" device, the noise can be reduced or eliminated. It is also possible to filter the noise somewhat using sound filters in the Final Cut Pro suite of programs. I like intellectually stimulating videos like you have done. 1 : Helpful Not Helpful
michael
7:26 am Tuesday
Jan 18, 2011
Do you know Casey Kaufman - also works for Al Jaz. He won an award from us last year for his VJ work in Gaza. Here's the story - http://vimeo.com/11648023 Check it out. Helpful Not Helpful
RhodriDavies
3:41 am Tuesday
Jan 18, 2011
Yep Helpful Not Helpful
michael
4:01 pm Monday
Jan 17, 2011
Do you work for Al Jaz? Helpful Not Helpful
RhodriDavies
11:07 am Monday
Jan 17, 2011
Hi Michael, All excellent points, thanks. I actually shot this before starting the NYVS courses so so now have a much clearer idea on the narrative arc, and yes your points concerning putting the character at the centre of the story are ringing true. Thanks, Rhodri Helpful Not Helpful